…………………where did music and speech come from?
– New Scientist, Dec, 2011.
– Frank Wilczek, Nobel laureate, EDGE, Sept, 2011.
– Stanislas Dehaene, author of Reading in the Brain.
– Daniel Simons, author of The Invisible Gorilla.
– Seth Horowitz, author of The Universal Sense.
– Bill Benzon, author of Beethoven’s Anvil.
– David Rothenberg, author of Survival of the Beautiful.
– Cynthia Knight, Library Journal, October, 2011.
– Julie Sedivy, Psychology Today, Dec, 2011.
– Discover Magazine, Sept, 2011.
– Frank Bures, Scientific American MIND, November, 2011.
– Richard P. Grant, The Scientist, January, 2012.
– Zac Shaw, Mediapocalypse, June, 2012.
– Faenosphere, Dec, 2012.
– Daniel Levitin, Wall Street Journal, October, 2011.
– Bob Holmes, New Scientist, Aug, 2011.
– Maria Popova, Brain Pickings, Aug, 2011.
– David DiSalvo, Forbes, Aug, 2011.
– Richard Kade, Leonardo, Aug, 2011.
– David Bradley Euroscientist, Sept, 2011.
My new book appeared in 2011, titled…
HARNESSED: How Language and Music Mimicked Nature and Transformed Ape to Man (Benbella, 2011)
Language and music are central to what it means to be human. But where did they come from? In Harnessed, cognitive scientist Changizi argues that language and music are in us not because we evolved for them, but, rather, because they evolved for us. Over history, language and music came to have the structure that our non-language and amusical brains could brilliantly absorb.
In particular, language and music came to have the structures of the sounds in nature, just the sorts of sounds our brain had evolved to process. It is this “nature-harnessing” that explains who we are today.
For speech, Changizi provides a barrage of evidence that speech across human languages mimics the fundamental sounds of physical events in the world. By mimicking the sounds that solid objects make when they hit, slide and ring, speech harnesses our ancient event-recognition powers that were never intended for language.
And, for music, Changizi lays out his case that music mimics another equally important category of sound in the world: the sounds of human movement. Just as we possess brains specially designed to recognize facial expressions, our brains evolved to recognize what people are doing in our midst from the sounds they make. Music harnesses that ancient brain capability, turning a human action recognition system into a music appreciation machine.
Written in Changizi’s personable, anecdotal style with helpful chapter summaries, Harnessed appeals to both the science enthusiast and the scientifically challenged reader, unveiling how, by mimicking natural events, cultural evolution molded languages and music to fit human brains.
——-
Here is a short overview…
If one of our non-speaking ancestors were found frozen in a glacier and revived, we imagine that he would find our world jarringly alien. The concrete, the cars, the clothes, the constant jabbering – it’s enough to make a hominid jump into the nearest freezer and hope to be reawoken after the apocalypse. But would modernity really seem so frightening to our guest? Although cities and savannas would appear to have little in common, might there be deep similarities? Could civilization have retained vestiges of nature, easing our ancestor’s transition?
Although we were born into civilization rather than thawed into it, from an evolutionary point of view we’re an uncivilized beast dropped into cultured society. We prefer nature as much as the next hominid, in the sense that our brains work best when their computationally sophisticated mechanisms can be applied as evolutionarily intended. One might, then, expect that civilization will have been shaped over time to possess signature features of nature, thereby squeezing every drop of evolution’s genius for use in the modern world.
Does civilization mimic nature? In his new book, HARNESSED, Mark Changizi argues that the most fundamental pillars of humankind are thoroughly infused with signs of the ancestral world. Those pillars are language and music. Cultural evolution over time has led to language and music designed as a simulacra of nature, so that they can be nearly effortlessly utilized by our ancient brains. Languages have evolved so that words look like natural objects when written and sound like natural events when spoken. And music has come to have the signature auditory patterns of people moving in one’s midst.
But if the key to our human specialness rests upon powers likely found in our non-linguistic hominid ancestors, then it suggests we are our non-linguistic hominid ancestors. Our thawed ancestors may do just fine here because our language would harness their brain as well. Rather than jumping into a freezer, our long-lost relative may choose instead to enter engineering school and invent the next generation of refrigerator. The origins of language and music may be attributable not to brains having evolved language or music instincts, but, rather, to language and music having culturally evolved brain instincts. Language and music shaped themselves over many thousands of years to be tailored for our brains, and because our brains were cut for nature, language and music mimicked nature. …transforming ape to man.
==
Some press on the book:
-
Blog Talk Radio:
Interview on Harnessed. -
Salt Lake Tribune:
Interview on Harnessed. -
Discover Mag:
Review of HARNESSED. -
KatiePhD:
Strange Overtones. -
Eureka:
Press release for HARNESSED. -
Wall Street Journal:
Masters of Distraction. -
New Scientist, Bob Holmes:
The sounds of movement. -
Science and Religion:
What Is Nature-Harnessing? -
Huff/AOL:
Is Language Technology? -
Forbes, David DiSalvo:
Reviews HARNESSED. -
WNYC, Soundcheck, John Schaefer:
Music: Transforming Ape to Man. -
WNYC, Soundcheck, John Schaefer:
NPR Radio interview on HARNESSED. -
MSNBC, Nidhi Subbaraman:
CosmicLog on my HARNESSED. -
TIME, Maia Szalavitz:
Understanding Why Music Moves Us. -
Hear It Now, Scott Prebys:
NPR Radio interview on HARNESSED. -
InnovationNewsDaily, Jeremy Hsu:
The future of humans, and harnessing. -
BrainPickings, Maria Popova:
Discusses HARNESSED. -
SciAm:
Excerpt from HARNESSED. -
WIRED, print:
Harnessed, and how apes became human. -
Late Night Live, Phillip Adams:
Harnessed interview. - Wall Street Journal, Pia Catton:
Dancing Out of the Dark - Neuroanthropology, Daniel Lende:
Culture Harnessing the Brain - Dr. Kiki:
Theoretically Thinking - Internet Actu:
Utiliser le cerveau pour le faire évoluer
Some pieces I have written relating to the upcoming book are collected here:
- Freakonomics: Rise of the Apes via Miracle Grow
- HUFF: Falling Skies and Harnessing
- HUFF: Is Language a Technology
- WIRED: The Secret Sauce in Language and Music
- SEED: Humans, version 3.0
- Neuroanthropology: What Speech Really Sounds Like
- The Atlantic: Where Does Music Come From
- Psychology Today: Why Humans Are So Smart…and Groovy
- ChangiziBlog: The Moving Look of Music: What Your Visual System Thinks Music Is
- ChangiziBlog: What Must a Theory of Music Explain?
- ChangiziBlog: How To Put Art And Brain Together
- ChangiziBlog: Why We Like 3D Movies — It’s Not Because of the 3D!
- ChangiziBlog: What We Are, In the Eyes of Alien Probers
- ChangiziBlog: Music Sounds Like Moving People
- Scientific American: Why does music make us feel?
- Psychology Today: Stephen Pinker’s Miracle of Language…and Writing?
Mark Changizi is Director of Human Cogntion at 2ai Labs, and the author of two previous books, The Vision Revolution (Benbella, 2009) and The Brain from 25000 Feet (Kluwer, 2003).




[...] Book: HARNESSED [...]
[...] Book: HARNESSED [...]
[...] Book: HARNESSED [...]
[...] Book: HARNESSED [...]
[...] Mark Changizi kommer 2011 ut med en bok om sin teori om musik. [...]
I look forward to reading your book. I am researching similar topics, as well. I think there are many things we see around us – if we trace back their history far enough – which mimick nature. What is also interesting is how “nature” mimicks humans (i.e. birds and car alarms).
That’s funny about the latter. In cases of birds mimicking car alarms, their own “bird culture” is evolving to sound like human-artifacts, thereby doing *something* — but what? — to other bird brains. Thanks! -Mark
@ changizi: You’re welcome! I’m deeply fascinated in the relationship between human / nature relationship and the ways in which humans have been practicing what today’s scientific community might call biomimicry. By chance would you happen to have any knowledge / evidence of a connection between human-made tools such as projectile points being a form of ancient “biomimicry”? My hypothesis is that ancient stone and bone tools were imitations of animal parts with points, such as teeth. All I’ve got so far is the evidence of competition and between Australopithecus and predators such as bears and sabre-tooth cats, as well as a predator-prey relationship between the latter and the former. From a cognitive approach would it sound reasonable that Australopithecus may have sought design inspiration from body parts such as teeth of their predators / competitors?
It sounds reasonable, certainly, and a fun hypothesis. No expertise on my part, though, to help.
[...] Book: HARNESSED [...]
Looking forward to reading this book! I am hearing science major and currently preparing my exams for speech perception. Looks like the book is much more interesting than those research papers!
Godel changed my way thinking and I am not a mathematician of any kind. It is obvious to me that he was a very special person who built a requirement that forced a new way by showing the error of the previous. I think that he wanted to move “the art of symbol” to the next level but, he did not have proof, and speculation was not allowed. I believe he was certain that new forms would evolve in advanced math. We are about to see that new horizon soon I believe and it will be a epiphany for us all. We will easily understand what before we could not have known. That new way of “language” may have arrived already and it is preparing for reveal. The hairs on my neck tell me that any moment some bright mind will know and share even if it take the rest of us some considerable time to catch up. The fruit is ripe.
I have not purchased a book in years but, I did this one and, I look forward to the read. GREAT SUBJECT!